Volcano House Hot Buttered Rum

Volcano House Hot Buttered Rum post image

Hot Buttered Rum is a frequent holiday drink that frequently finds itself at the business end of tinkering.  In a recent post I discussed the essential or basic Hot Buttered Rum, a simple mixture of rum, butter, hot water, sugar, and spices.  Any drink that exists as long as Hot Buttered Rum is bound to be tweaked and modified and turned into other drinks, and Jeff “Beachbum” Berry turned me on to this particular variation.

Volcano House Hot Buttered Rum

1.5 oz Rum
.75 oz Sugar
.75 oz Lemon Juice
.25 oz Maraschino
Hot Black Tea

Place juice, sugar, maraschino, and rum into a pre-heated mug.  Add hot tea.  Stir and then float the butter.  Garnish with lemon peel and cloves.

This recipe hearkens from the 1950’s, when Bob Ida of the Volcano House Hotel on the Big Island of Hawaii bestowed it upon the world.  I had asked a group of mixologists for some of their favorite winter rum drinks, and Jeff was nice enough to share this recipe, which will be appearing in his upcoming book, Beach Bum Berry Remixed.


If you’re unfamiliar with The Bum, you should definitely take the time to go and hunt down his other books.  Every one is chock-full of great recipes and the history behind some of the best Tiki drinks ever concocted by concoctioneers that were busy concocting their crazy concoctions.

This particular recipe is, quite frankly, butterly delicious.  With the right rum this drink is both sweet and earthy, with the richness of the butter making it truly something to savor.  If you have access to a great Jamaican or Demerara rum, I recommend using one of those, preferably over and over again until the bottle is empty.

Comments on this entry are closed.

  • Chris

    December 3, 2009, 08:30

    After your last two posts I’m wondering if I couldn’t tweak a Voodoo Princess into a HBR variety. The spices are similiar. I’m excited to try the Volcano House HBR tonight.*

    *Daytime high 28 today with flurries.

  • Chris

    December 3, 2009, 08:31

    Sorry, Voodoo Priestess!

  • Paul Etter

    December 3, 2009, 13:44

    I just picked up a bottle of Smith & Cross Jamaican pot still rum that I will be subbing for the normal Coruba that I use in this recipe. As a bonus, it’s been unusually cold lately in San Francisco. I think it dropped down into the 50’s last night.

  • Blair, aka Trader Tiki

    December 4, 2009, 10:48

    Have you tried using different sugar subs, such as honey, or better yet, molasses? Might be interesting to get a real hot Black Strap flavor coming out of there.

    I’ll admit, Maraschino liqueur does not sound at all good heated, but I’ll try (almost) anything once!

  • TikiGeeki

    December 8, 2009, 17:37

    Didn’t have all the ingredients, but I did have enough to try a variation (I also had a volcano mug that fit 2 cups worth so I doubled the amounts):

    3 oz Kraken Rum
    1.5 oz lemon juice (1 lemon)
    1.5 oz simple syrup
    .5 oz Triple Sec
    10 oz Earl Grey tea
    dash of ground cloves

    Quite the citrus kick indeed! Very good!

  • HB

    November 20, 2011, 15:03

    Brewed a pot of chai with added ginger, pepper, star anise and assorted citrus peels. Great spicy base for the butter and our San Diego local Ballast Point rum!

Next post:

Previous post: